Dating Outside Your Type: Why “Curveball Crushing” Could Be the Best Thing for Your Love Life
Curveball crushing means falling for someone outside your usual type. Here’s why it works, how to try it, and why it can help neurodivergent daters.
In short
Dating outside your type, now nicknamed “curveball crushing”, means giving a real chance to someone who doesn’t match the picture you usually swipe for. It isn’t about lowering your standards: it’s about separating your core values (respect, honesty, kindness) from surface preferences like height, style or music taste. For neurodivergent daters, whose best qualities often don’t show up in a quick swipe, it can be the difference between being overlooked and being properly seen.
What is curveball crushing?
The term comes from a Cosmopolitan India feature published on 17 November 2026, which describes it as finding yourself attracted to someone who falls completely outside your usual type: the person you’d normally scroll past, the friend you never considered romantically, or someone whose interests are the opposite of yours.
The piece argues that because dating apps make it so easy to filter by everything from height to hobbies, many of us have become attached to a very specific idea of who we “should” be dating. Curveball crushing is the pushback: loosen the checklist and let attraction surprise you.
It lands in the same week NPR’s It’s Been a Minute asked whether our impossibly high standards are ruining dating, looking at “strict” dating, where people rule out potential partners over minor things, and whether that rigidity is shrinking the dating pool and taking the fun out of it.
Is it bad to have a “type”?
No. Knowing what you find attractive is normal and healthy. As the Cosmopolitan article puts it, preferences only become a problem when they turn into non-negotiables. If you’ve always dated people with the same personality, lifestyle or look, you may be limiting your options without realising it, especially if those relationships keep ending the same way.
A useful test: ask whether a preference tells you anything about how someone will treat you. Whether they’re six foot, dress a certain way or share your taste in films says very little. Whether they’re consistent, honest and emotionally available says almost everything.
Is dating outside your type the same as lowering your standards?
No, and this is the most important distinction. Standards are about behaviour and values: respect, honesty, emotional maturity, consistency and shared expectations. Those are worth holding on to. Preferences are about packaging. Curveball crushing asks you to relax the second, never the first.
If something about a match makes you feel unsafe or uncomfortable, that’s not a “type” issue. Trust it. (Our guide to green flags when dating someone new can help you tell the difference.)
Why does this matter for neurodivergent daters?
Swipe culture rewards a very narrow set of signals: the perfect photo, the witty opening line, instant sparkle on a first date. Many autistic people, people with ADHD and other neurodivergent daters don’t come across at their best in those first few seconds, and it’s not because they have less to offer.
- Attraction can build slowly. The Cosmopolitan piece notes that humour, kindness and confidence often become more attractive the more you get to know someone. For people who are anxious, masking or processing a lot of sensory input on a date, that slower build is often where the real connection lives. We explored this in how to tell if you’re compatible on a first date.
- Filters can screen out great people. A rigid checklist can rule out someone who communicates differently, has an unusual passion, or doesn’t “perform” well on a profile.
- Your own type may be a pattern, not a preference. If you keep falling for the same kind of person and it keeps hurting, it may be worth asking why. Our post on ghosting and attachment styles is a good place to start.
“There’s a famous saying that what people think they want isn’t who they normally end up with. By all means, have some qualities you’re looking for in a person, but a huge checklist means you’re writing off people who might be a great fit for you. This is why Mattr is a great option: you already know the people there are comfortable dating someone ‘different’, so you don’t need to go through that process, and you can focus on what else they have to offer. I’ve dated many different people in my life, but the one who made me happiest was the one who accepted me for me. That’s the main thing you should be looking for!”
Jamie Johnston, dating expert and founder of Mattr
Looking for people who get it? Mattr is the dating app and community for anyone who feels "different", built so neurodivergent daters can be themselves from the first message. It’s free to join, with the option to upgrade. Download the Mattr app or Visit Mattr.social.
How do you start dating outside your type?
Drawing on the Cosmopolitan advice, plus what works for neurodivergent daters:
- Slow down the left swipe. Before passing on someone, read their whole profile. What would they be like to spend a Sunday with?
- Separate your list into two columns. “Must have” (values and behaviour) and “nice to have” (looks, height, hobbies). Only the first column is a dealbreaker.
- Start a conversation you’d normally skip. Ask about something on their profile that you know nothing about. Curiosity is a great antidote to nerves.
- Say yes to a low-pressure first date. A coffee or a walk is enough. You don’t have to force attraction; you just need enough time to find out if there’s something there.
- Give it more than one date. If the first meeting felt comfortable and safe but not fireworks, a second date is often where things change. (If dating apps are wearing you out, read our guide to dating app burnout.)
- Let it be fine if it doesn’t work out. The point isn’t to find a partner at any cost. It’s to stop treating your preferences like a fixed formula.
FAQ
What does curveball crushing mean?
Curveball crushing means being attracted to, or choosing to date, someone outside your usual type, such as a friend you never saw romantically or someone with very different interests or style.
Why do I keep dating the same type?
Familiarity feels safe, and dating app filters reinforce it. If the same type keeps leading to the same disappointments, it may be a pattern worth questioning rather than a preference worth protecting.
Is dating outside your type a good idea?
It can be, as long as your core standards stay the same. Being open on looks, hobbies or lifestyle can widen your dating pool without compromising on respect, honesty or kindness.
Is dating outside your type harder if you’re neurodivergent?
It can feel daunting, but it often works in your favour: neurodivergent daters tend to shine once there’s time to connect, which is exactly what curveball crushing encourages. A community that understands neurodiversity, like Mattr, makes that easier.
Where can neurodivergent people meet open-minded matches?
Mattr is a dating app and community for neurodivergent people and anyone who feels "different". It’s free to join, with the option to upgrade, at mattr.social.
The bottom line
Your type isn’t a rulebook. Keep your standards high and your preferences flexible, and you’ll give yourself, and the people who don’t fit the usual mould, a far better chance of a real connection.
Ready to meet someone who gets you?
Join Mattr to find people who are already comfortable dating someone “different”. It’s free to join, with the option to upgrade.
Sources
- Sagarika Choudhary (17 November 2026). “Curveball crushing is the healthy dating trend making us rethink our type”, Cosmopolitan India.
- NPR, It’s Been a Minute (17 November 2026). Our impossibly high standards are ruining dating.
Free to join, with the option to upgrade. Visit Mattr.social